Search
Writing

November Match Analysis

By AIDAN CONNOR

In the fourth edition of our regular series, Aidan Connor analyses Celtic’s performances and results for the month of November. The six matches included three matches in the Scottish Premiership, the League Cup semi Final and two away matches in the Europa League campaign.

Game One: Celtic 3-1 Rangers – Scottish League Cup Semi Final

The Skipper scored a magnificent goal

We arrived at Hampden with everything still fresh from the previous week; Rodgers’ departure, Desmond’s statement, protests at the Parkhead gates. That context was important. What we saw on the pitch was an immediate change in tone from what we’d seen before. O’Neill and his staff set up the side in a 4-3-3, but the individual tactical player changes were pragmatic enough to shift from Rodgers’ slow, boring 4-3-3 play to give us more protection through the middle and allow the wing-backs to get up and down. The plan eliminated many of the slow, overly complicated patterns that had been strangling us, replacing them with clearer roles and simpler triggers – press, quick transitions, and channel attack. Engels and McGregor’s double pivots formed a compact central spine. Engels sat comfortably and recycled the ball forward, while McGregor could step into pockets to receive and probe. That double pivot enabled us to control the middle third more aggressively than we had in weeks. With Scales and Trusty as the central pairing, we were dominant in duels, and it allowed us to play clearer, faster vertical passes into the striker through the midfield rather than the endless sideways circulation that had previously been our trademark. The system also encouraged the forwards to run in behind and attack second balls. Saracchi started instead of Tierney, indicating a shift in balance. Saracchi in particular stood out all night – we forget he has captained Uruguay. He covered a lot of ground, provided good overlapping support, and stretched Rangers’ right side. Ralston’s energy on the right provided width and defensive cover, which combined to make the flanks a real focus. Nonetheless, there were moments when our concentration wavered. We conceded a penalty as a result of a decision that most of us couldn’t understand, but the team’s tactical shape limited the damage and kept us competitive. 

The Trusty incident, in which his challenge to Butland was “severe”, has created a debate after the match around officiating. Rohl and the Rangers camp have made noise about it since. Trusty was rightly booked, but the decision to give only yellow, despite the fact that Rangers had lost a man, added to the postgame discussion about consistency and control in big games. Rangers felt it should have been a red… it’s not a red. Whatever you think of the referee calls, we can take comfort in the fact that the team did not give up after the nonsense, we remained calm and carried out the plan. The challenge itself was the type of challenge where you won the ball, but your technique put you in danger. The referee’s decision to book him rather than dismiss him was likely the only time all night that a contentious call went our way, and it came wrapped in the same inconsistency that has plagued this fixture for years. Earlier in the game, Aasgaard was rightfully sent off for a reckless tackle on Ralston, and then Ralston received a handball penalty that no one in the stadium, including the replays, could understand. What mattered most was how the team responded. We didn’t lose our cool, we didn’t let Rangers’ complaints or the crowd noise derail us, and Trusty himself settled back into the game rather than panicking. In a game marked by emotional swings, contentious decisions, and a referee struggling for control, the Trusty moment summed up the chaos while also emphasising something we’ve lacked lately – composure under scrutiny, even when the spotlight is shining. 

In extra time, Callum McGregor’s goal felt like it brought the entire night back into our control, and it came from a part of his game that is still underappreciated – his shooting. People talk about his press resistance, tempo-setting, and leadership, but they forget, or perhaps simply ignore, that McGregor has always had a strike in him. This was another reminder of that. The ball sits up, he shapes himself with a single touch, and then he lashes it with that clean, flat technique he’s perfected over the years. It wasn’t a hit-and-hope. Butland could have done better from the strike, but the timing was crucial in making it so successful. We were wobbling, the legs were heavy, and the emotion of the penalty and the officiating nonsense was still lingering, and then McGregor, who had spent weeks playing within himself under Rodgers, steps up. He’s a match-winner who has been scoring goals like that for a decade; in Europe, derbies, and cup finals, from 20-25 yards with his trademark whip or drive. The way he shaped his body, the way he struck through the centre of the ball, the way he meant it. It was the finish of a player who understood that the moment demanded something decisive. 

It has to be said that another important factor in this game that has struck supporters as much as the goals themselves is how quickly Kenny and Osmand have progressed from fringe players to true sources of energy in this team. Kenny was forced to step in due to injuries, and instead of looking like a stopgap, he seized the opportunity like he’d been waiting for it. Alongside him, Osmand’s extra-time finish felt like the beginning of a proper striking duo, two hungry kids forcing their way into the conversation. When young forwards believe and feel trusted, they play with confidence that money cannot buy. Part of this is due to the atmosphere around them. The temporary coaching staff isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel, they’re simply tightening the details, keeping the message clear, and reminding the players that no one succeeds on their own. That sense of unity, of everyone working together, is exactly what this team has been missing. 

For Osmand, that moment in the semi-final felt like the beginning of something larger. You could see it in the way he celebrated, not as a kid who had scored a cameo goal, but as someone who truly believes he belongs here. And it’s easy to forget how long he’s waited for even the smallest opportunity. Months of being stuck on the periphery, travelling with squads but barely kicking a ball, trying not to feel like a backup player. That takes a toll on a young player, especially one who has moved country and isn’t sure what his place is yet. However, the goal was not a fluke or a

flash but was the reward for remaining prepared, keeping his head down, and refusing to mope. Most impressively, he did not get carried away, talking about building on it, earning the right to stay on the team, and demonstrating that he’s more than just a one-off. That’s precisely the mindset we require –  hungry, grounded, and desperate to make the most of his time with us. 

Game Two: Midtyland 3-1 Celtic: Europa League

A miserable night in Denmark

We arrived in Denmark with genuine belief. O’Neill raising expectations of what we could achieve this season, and bringing a renewed sense of competitiveness, resilience and identity around the team. However, within the first half, any illusion of a balanced battle was dashed. Midtjylland ripped us apart in brutal fashion, scoring three goals in eight minutes with precision, timing, and menace. It wasn’t just that they scored, it was how they did so. Erlič’s header, Kruger-Johnsen’s expertly lifted finish, and Dju’s blast were clinical but also exposed a Celtic side that appeared sluggish. The physical dominance was obvious, but their tactical execution gave the impression that we lacked a coherent structure to stem the tide. When Midtjylland attacked, they exploited the gaps, either running in behind our midfield or overloading the wide areas. Our midfield, which is capable of controlling tempo, was bypassed, and too often our defenders were forced into isolated positions, chasing runners with no support ahead or behind them. Instead of providing a base, our shape looked brittle and reactive. We were chasing shadows rather than dictating play. At this level, such structural fragility is fatal. Statistically, the match reads as a rout. Facing fifteen shots in the first half, the most we’ve ever conceded in a European opening 45 since 2012,  isn’t just a blip or bad luck; it’s a warning signal. Midtjylland’s intensity and efficiency were frightening, and if we’re honest, we were lucky it stayed at 3–0 going into the break. The dominance they exerted was not flattered by their scoreline, it was a reflection of how badly we were second-best in almost every department. When teams perform like that against us in Europe, it’s not just a tactical failure but an existential reminder that we may not yet be equipped to compete consistently at this level. 

In the second half, there was some attempt at recovery with a switch in mindset, if not an overhaul in system. The wing-backs tucked in more frequently, midfielders made better decisions about when to press and when to drop, and we began to limit Midtjylland’s freedom to roam. But our attacking game, already underpowered, failed to produce the kind of momentum that could genuinely threaten a turnaround. The supply to our front line lacked urgency and final balls were sluggish and predictable. When the chance came via a penalty, thanks to Osmand’s challenge, Hatate put it in with composure. That goal offered a sliver of hope, and for a moment, the tempo shifted. But it felt more like the cost of damage limitation than a launchpad for any genuine fightback. If we’re brutally honest, this wasn’t simply “we were weaker” or “they were the better team.” This was a poor performance. And the responsibility lies on multiple fronts. Yes, O’Neill must shoulder blame. He selected a formation that did not suit the way our defenders handled the pressure, and his side looked underprepared for the physical and mental onslaught. But it’s not solely on him, the players failed to impose themselves, made too many basic errors, and lacked the ruthless edge that European nights demand. Perhaps most worryingly, this points to a broader club issue. Are we still recruiting for European standards? Does the hierarchy truly believe we can fight in this competition, or are we content with showing up, even when the gulf is evident? The cracks from this game expose not one but several very real vulnerabilities. 

This game also forces us to face a harsh reality about the level at which we function as a team. There is a difference between performing well in domestic games, even against strong rivals like Rangers, and producing anything resembling consistency on the European stage. Some players appear decisive and capable against the physicality and pace of the Scottish Premiership, but when faced with a team like Midtjylland, they struggle to make basic contributions. It raises uncomfortable questions, such as whether a player who excels domestically but struggles in Europe is truly suitable for Celtic. Are we building a team that can only dominate a low-intensity league, or are we assembling players who can compete at multiple levels? For us as supporters, it’s clear that domestic form alone is insufficient to assess quality; a player’s ability to meet the demands of European football must be the standard. Otherwise, we risk fielding a team capable of winning derbies but unable to survive or progress against teams of comparable or slightly higher quality in Europe, trapping us in the “good at home, vulnerable abroad” cycle. 

Game Three: Celtic 4-0 Kilmarnock: Scottish Premiership

A powerful display against Kilmarnock

After the European nightmare in Denmark, the match against Kilmarnock offered what we all thought might be Martin O’Neill’s final outing at Celtic Park – a chance to bow out gracefully and perhaps offer the supporters one last lap of honour. Yet, even without any celebratory gestures, there was a sense that O’Neill knew this wouldn’t be his last match just yet, that the work at the club isn’t finished and the players still need him. From the first whistle, Celtic were back to asserting themselves in a way that reminded us why this club has dominated domestically over the years. Johnny Kenny’s early tap-in after some atrocious defending from Kilmarnock settled any nerves lingering from the Midtjylland humiliation. The team created chance after chance. 

Tierney, reintroduced after Saracchi went off injured, showed why he remains a key figure for us despite his quiet return to Celtic so far, fizzing a strike into the far corner in the second half to extend the lead and remind everyone of his class and timing.

Maeda’s late finish, followed by Engels’ cool penalty, added gloss to a scoreline that could have been even more emphatic, reflecting not only Kilmarnock’s deficiencies with their defenders repeatedly misjudging positioning and goalkeeper Eddie Beach failing to command his box, but also the sharpness and intent of our side once the players were allowed to express themselves without hesitation.  Tactically, we focused on dominating the centre of the pitch, pressing aggressively, and transitioning quickly into attack, exploiting the gaps in Kilmarnock’s defensive line. The game also highlighted O’Neill’s man-management skill by rotating the squad and giving opportunities to players like Simpson-Pusey, who was playing right-back on his debut even though he was signed as central-defence cover. The absence of a lap of honour, perhaps understated, felt symbolic – a quiet acknowledgement that the real work is ongoing, that this victory, however welcome, is not the end of the story, and that O’Neill remains a stabilising presence for us as we look to reclaim dominance in Scotland and build credibility abroad. 

Johnny Kenny’s rise to the starting striker role is one of the key stories from this game and a sign of the evolution in our squad. Once considered a promising youth prospect, Kenny has gradually transformed into a reliable first-team option through this month. Combining pace, clever movement, and an instinct in front of goal. His positioning for the opener, staying alert to Hatate’s intelligent pass and reacting faster than any of Kilmarnock’s defence and their goalkeeper, showed maturity and composure. Kenny is now beginning to establish himself as a genuine threat in the Premiership, and performances like this cement his place as a central piece in O’Neill’s plans. This isn’t just a one-off. Kenny’s consistency and work rate across the season indicate a player growing into the role of Celtic’s starting striker. Benjamin Nygren continued his fine form, showing just how pivotal he is to Celtic’s attack. With five goals and two assists, he has been directly involved in 44% of our league goals this season, illustrating the heavy reliance we place on him. His vision, technique, and timing in the final third allow him to create opportunities out of almost nothing, and his movement often drags defenders out of position, opening spaces for teammates. Against Kilmarnock, Nygren’s combination play with Hatate and Kenny demonstrated the kind of intelligent attacking football that makes Celtic so dangerous at home. 

Finally, while the game provided relief and allowed O’Neill to lead the team to a dominant victory, the circumstances surrounding the game were equally telling. Given the humiliation at Midtjylland, many expected this to be O’Neill’s final match in charge, but the lack of a lap of honour and the manager’s calm professionalism suggested he may have already known this wasn’t his farewell. This game demonstrated that Celtic are still capable of execution and discipline when given the right setup, focus, and mental approach. It was a reassuring return to domestic form, but it also served as a stark reminder that the club’s ultimate goal remains to close the gap in European football, or the fans goal at least…

Game Four: St Mirren 0-1 Celtic: Scottish Premiership

The Skipper AGAIN Stood up

Our 1-0 win over St Mirren was far from our finest hour. For much of the match, we were second-best, limited to hopeful long-range shots and the occasional probing run into the box. It wasn’t pretty, and for long stretches, we struggled to impose ourselves against a disciplined St Mirren side, whose compact shape and sharp counter-attacks kept us at arm’s length. Kenny was taken off at halftime after a quiet performance, a reminder that while some of our players can shine against weaker opposition, we still lack attacking variety and depth when faced with a well-organised defence. It was a frustrating watch, and at times, it felt like we were chasing the game rather than controlling it, a pattern that has cropped up too often this season. 

The overall quality of the game was poor. There was very little to write home about, largely because St Mirren were so tactically well set up and limited our opportunities almost entirely. Their defensive organisation stifled us from the first whistle to the last, making even basic attacking moves difficult to execute. It is worrying that a team we are expected to beat comfortably was able to contain us so effectively, especially with the cup final against them looming. Watching our attacks repeatedly cut short or forced wide was a harsh reminder that moments of brilliance alone cannot carry us in key games. We need to be sharper, quicker, and more cohesive if we are to avoid being caught out by opponents who study us carefully and exploit our weaknesses. The moment when St. Mirren had the goal offside after the shot bounced off scales leg into the net in my opinion should have stood,watching it I can’t really understand why that was taken away from St.Mirren. We were lucky. 

The breakthrough, when it finally came in the dying seconds, was when McGregor produced a shot of pure quality. Picking up the ball outside the box, he shaped it onto his left foot and let fly a thunderous shot into the top corner, leaving the goalkeeper stranded. It was not just technically brilliant, it was emblematic of our season so far, where individual brilliance often rescues us when the team struggles to create or dominate. As O’Neill said afterward, it was “a goal that probably didn’t belong to this match,” and he admitted that for long periods we had failed to take care of the ball or create enough chances. That strike perfectly summed up the fine margins in a season that has been defined by inconsistency and moments of both promise and frustration. 

The win, despite its scrappy nature, had real implications. We closed the gap on Hearts to four points, keeping hope alive in the title race, and it gave the squad a boost of confidence heading into a crucial stretch of fixtures. But it also served as a reminder that heroics alone won’t be enough if we want to mount a serious challenge domestically and accomplish anything in Europe. Structural improvements, tactical adjustments, and mental resilience are needed if we are to turn narrow escapes into

routine victories. O’Neill understands this, and after the game he spoke to the team about enjoying the victory, even when it comes hard, emphasising that confidence and morale are just as important as skill or strategy. That psychological edge can be the difference between scraping through a tough match and collapsing under pressure, and right now it feels like we’re beginning to reclaim that mentality. This match highlighted both the frustrations and the hope that come with following this team and season. We’re still very much in the hunt for the Premiership, but if we want to turn sporadic heroics into consistent dominance, we need to address the weaknesses that have held us back all season – goals. Moments like McGregor’ are thrilling, but they are also a warning that unless we fix our structure, develop our attacking variety, and maintain composure against well-drilled sides, games like this could easily go the other way, especially in the bigger fixtures ahead. 

Game Five: Feyenoord 1-3 Celtic: Europa League

A remarkable night in Rotterdam

Our 3–1 victory in Rotterdam felt like a night when old shadows were finally shaken off. For years, European nights have been frustrating, often leaving us feeling powerless and disappointed, but this away win was more than three points, it was a reclamation of belief. Returning to the city where the heartbreak of the 1970 European Cup final unfolded added a symbolic weight to the occasion. That night, our predecessors were toppled on one of football’s grandest stages, and the echoes of that defeat have lingered through decades of near-misses in Europe. But this night, our performance was disciplined yet daring, wounded yet resilient, delivered with a conviction that has too often been missing on continental nights. 

The early minutes were tense and reminded us why Europe has been so unforgiving. Feyenoord carved through our defence with a single long pass, allowing Ayase Ueda to finish clinically. In previous seasons, such a setback might have triggered panic and chaos, but this time we absorbed the blow, regrouped, and gradually began to impose ourselves. Yang Hyun-jun’s brilliant equaliser, a first-time finish into the corner, shifted the momentum entirely. Just twelve minutes later, Daizen Maeda’s relentless pressing forced a defensive mistake, allowing Reo Hatate to slot the ball home into an empty net. Suddenly, the game had flipped on its head. We were assertive yet measured, combining tactical clarity with emotional composure, pressing Feyenoord high, exploiting spaces in transition, and demonstrating a maturity that has often been missing from our European away days. We defended collectively, absorbed pressure intelligently, and moved the ball quickly and decisively when opportunities arose, showing balance between patience and aggression. 

Individually, Yang epitomised the resurgence of this team under O’Neil. Operating on the left, he showed boldness, creativity, and technical flair, taking defenders on,

driving into space, and refusing to retreat under pressure. His performance reflected the transformation Martin O’Neill has nurtured, the confidence to take risks, learn from mistakes, and demand the ball in key moments. Yang’s equaliser wasn’t just a goal but a statement that he can contribute to this team. Benjamin Nygren also played a pivotal role, and it was his thunderous strike off the underside of the bar that sealed the night. Watching that goal hit the back of the net was euphoric – our first European away win in the Netherlands since 2001. Nygren’s strike wasn’t just a highlight, it was the icing on the cake, a culmination of composure, precision, and ruthlessness that has often deserted us in away ties in Europe. 

The second half demanded control, patience, and nerve, and we delivered both. We managed possession, frustrated Feyenoord into long periods of passivity, and absorbed their counter-attacks with disciplined defending. Balls were hacked off the line, shots blocked, and Schmeichel made key interventions when required. Defensive discipline, collective effort, mental resilience, and luck defined our performance. We could have panicked and conceded 3 goals in 8 minutes as against Midtyland, but every player contributed to the structure that allowed us to see out the game. Looking at the wider context, this victory illustrated the potential of this squad. We thought Europe was a right-off this season, but in Rotterdam, everything aligned. Belief, structure, courage and talent all came together. It showed that when we play with conviction and clarity, we can overcome both historical and contemporary European obstacles. The win doesn’t erase remaining vulnerabilities and the defensive lapses, tactical adjustments, and cohesion still require work but it proves that we can mitigate them when preparation and mindset combine effectively. 

Game Six: Hibernian 1-2 Celtic: Scottish Premiership

A convincing win in the capital

Hibs came at us with genuine intent, ripping forward with speed and directness. Both Boyle and McGrath had early chances that could have caused real problems and their failure to convert those openings proved crucial. When we were handed opportunities of our own, we settled the game quickly. A poor pass from Sallinger allowed Hatate to pounce, and he showed composure to slide the ball across for Maeda to finish into an empty net. That goal calmed us and unsettled Hibs. 

The second goal arrived just thirty-three seconds later, a perfect example of the kind of bravery O’Neill has demanded from us. Yang’s cross looped into the six-yard box, and Engels launched himself forward, taking a boot to the face to head us into a two-goal lead. It was the kind of direct efficiency that had been missing earlier in the season, not waves of possession without penetration, but actions that turned chances into goals. Maeda’s clever backheel soon after fed Saracchi, whose low

strike hit the post, giving a brief glimpse that we might run riot. We were flowing, confident, and sharp, the football was expressive rather than cautious, everything that had been absent in September and October. 

The second half told a different story, revealing both old vulnerabilities and new-found resilience. Hibs pressed higher, attacked more directly, and turned our occasional sloppiness into sustained pressure. Their route back into the match came from a VAR-awarded penalty against Scales, a debatable decision, which Boyle dispatched perfectly. Suddenly, Easter Road lifted, and a game that had seemed under control at half-time became nervy. Cadden had the clearest chance to equalise, only to be denied by a superb Schmeichel save. 

Looking at the bigger picture, O’Neill’s impact has been profound. These are the same players Rodgers had, yet they now look physically energised, psychologically settled, and tactically liberated. Pressing is intentional, transitions are sharp, and key players, namely Maeda, Hatate, McGregor, and Yang, are producing consistently. O’Neill’s insistence on bravery, on repeating courageous actions even when they fail, has been transformative, especially for Yang. His assist for Engels’ goal was just one example of his growing reliability and his confidence on the ball shows how much trust O’Neill has coaxed from players who were previously dormant. 

Hatate’s resurgence cannot be overstated. His involvement in the first goal came from aggression and timing, but his broader first-half performance highlighted why we’ve struggled when he’s been out of form. He now provides verticality, vision, and unpredictability, three qualities that were missing during our most sluggish spells under Rodgers. O’Neill allows him to attempt riskier passes, press high, and dictate play rather than simply retain possession. Even when his influence dipped in the second half, the imprint of his early dominance remained crucial to our victory. 

Hibs, for their part, will leave frustrated yet encouraged. Their failure to convert early chances cost them dearly. Their response after going two down showed character which is more than many sides have displayed against us recently. Boyle’s penalty reignited belief, the midfield pushed higher, and Cadden’s late effort could easily have changed the narrative if it had not been stopped by Schmeichel. The story of the afternoon, however, was us rediscovering an identity that had slipped away over the past year. We weren’t perfect, and the final twenty minutes were nervy, but even in shakier spells, we played with purpose. The league table now reflects progress – two points behind Hearts with a game in hand, momentum shifting, belief growing. O’Neill hinted before kick-off that he would likely remain in charge for the upcoming Dundee match while Nancy’s paperwork is finalised. If this is indeed the closing chapter of his brief second spell, he leaves us with identity, confidence, and a reawakened sense of ourselves. 

By full-time, the win felt emblematic of our current state – not yet complete, not yet consistent, but undeniably on an upward path. Easter Road demanded perseverance as much as invention, and we found enough of both to prevail. The O’Neill bounce has become something deeper, not just a reaction, but a revival. As the club edges closer to a new era under Nancy, we do so in far better shape. One of the clearest reflections of Celtic’s recent transformation is Hyun-Jun Yang, now evolving from an erratic impact sub into a genuine ninety-minute contributor who affects games at both ends of the pitch. If Feyenoord midweek was the warning shot, the performance where he finally stitched an end product to his unpredictable dribbling, then Easter Road was the confirmation. He pressed with menace, carried the ball with confidence, and delivered the inch-perfect cross for Engels’ header. For a player who spent much of the past two seasons drifting in and out of matches, often too lightweight or inconsistent to be trusted from the start, he suddenly looks energised, decisive, and efficient. A goal last week, an assist this week, and two relentless performances signal a player who is discovering his identity at Celtic, not as a momentary spark but as a sustained threat. Under O’Neill, Yang is no longer playing like a project, he is playing like a starter. 

Reo Hatate, meanwhile, looks like a different footballer. Lighter, freer, and far more in tune with the rhythm of the game than at any point since the New Year. His press for the opening goal was not simply opportunistic but emblematic of a player who feels connected again. He passed with imagination, carried the ball with his old swagger, and moved with the sort of joy that had been missing for much of the campaign. Too often this season, Hatate has looked weighed down,  by expectation, by form, by the physical setbacks that repeatedly disrupted his flow. Here, though, he played with the brightness and authority that made him such a pivotal figure during Celtic’s strongest spells under Ange Postecoglou. Whether it is O’Neill’s man-management, tactical simplicity, or simply the reset he needed, he looks happier and more expressive, a midfielder reborn rather than repaired. 

Arne Engels deserves his own spotlight, because his rise under O’Neill has been as striking as anyone’s. When he first arrived, he looked a mix of raw quality and nerves, a talented midfielder who could press, run, and pass but too often seemed unsure of his role or hesitant in possession. Over the past few weeks, he has transformed into a commanding presence, playing with a conviction that makes everything around him look smoother. His headed goal at Easter Road – taken through a boot to the face – summed up his current mindset; brave, committed and willing to put himself in harm’s way for marginal gains. Beyond the goal, he dictated rhythm when Celtic needed calm, showed composure in transitions, and worked tirelessly out of possession. It is no coincidence that Celtic’s midfield looks more balanced since O’Neill arrived and Engels has been central to that shift, emerging as one of the side’s most reliable performers in an unexpectedly short period of time. 

Ultimately, Celtic’s win at Hibs was not just about the three points but the familiar feel of a functioning team. This was the Celtic that pressed with purpose, attacked with tempo, and defended with unity, even under strain. It was the Celtic of

last autumn; fast, brave, and unforgiving. The same squad that had looked short on ideas under Rodgers suddenly appears unlocked, energised, and expressive under O’Neill, whose brief tenure has been transformative in both spirit and identity. Six wins from seven is not an accident. It is the product of a manager who simplified roles, boosted confidence, and demanded intensity, and a group of players who responded. 

November closes with Celtic in a very different place than they were thirty days ago. We look revitalised, cohesive, and within striking distance at the top of the Premiership while still alive in Europe and competing for a trophy. O’Neill’s farewell game against Dundee now carries the emotional weight of gratitude rather than anxiety, because what he has delivered in this short spell is not merely results but direction. His final act comes just before Wilfried Nancy is officially appointed, stepping into a role that begins with a brutal ten-day gauntlet; top-of-the-table Hearts, a season-defining Europa League tie against Roma, and the League Cup final against St Mirren. Three massive fixtures that will shape Celtic’s winter and possibly their entire season. Nancy arrives in a club that has been stabilised, sharpened, and given a platform to build upon but the reality is simple, what comes next is make-or-break. The work O’Neill has done gives Celtic hope – what Nancy does with it will determine everything.

Join the discussion

More like this